How To Choose the Right Car Accident Lawyer in NY: What Questions To Ask

Car Accident Lawyer in NY

If you’ve been in a vehicle collision, then you likely know how overwhelming dealing with injuries, bodywork damage, and insurance companies can become. Contacting a New York car accident lawyer early in the process can make a difference in how you approach the claim or build your case. 

Below, Elliot Ifraimoff & Associates, PC, a car accident lawyer in New York, explains what questions to ask your potential accident attorney before you hire them.

Why You Might Need a Car Accident Lawyer in New York

According to the National Safety Council, an estimated 44,762 people died in traffic crashes across the United States during 2023. The numbers tell an equally sobering story about roadway safety in New York State. Based on data from the Department of Health, motor vehicle traffic crashes were the leading cause of injury-related deaths in New York between 2012 and 2014, with an average of 1,098 deaths and over 136,900 emergency room visits.

New York operates under a no-fault insurance system, which requires drivers to carry Personal Injury Protection auto insurance coverage. Under this system, if you’re injured in a car accident, you would likely file with your own insurance company first. However, if you suffer serious injuries during the accident, an insightful New York car accident lawyer may suggest filing a lawsuit against the at-fault driver, including pursuing pain and suffering and related damages that insurance won’t cover.

When you’re injured in a car accident, you need a legal representative who understands the law and the serious impact that these crashes have on victims’ lives. New York car accident laws can be complex, and insurance companies may try to minimize settlements. You also face strict deadlines with New York’s statute of limitations, which typically gives you three years from the date of the accident to file a personal injury lawsuit.

Key Questions To Ask Your Car Accident Attorney in New York

Choosing the right New York car accident lawyer starts with asking the right questions. Does the attorney have the experience and the approach your case needs? Our car accident legal guide includes some questions below to help you find out.

What Experience Do You Have With Cases Like Mine?

What is the attorney’s background? Ask how long they have practiced personal injury law and how many car accident cases they have handled annually. A reliable car accident lawyer in Queens, NY, should be happy to share their track record, including details about whether they have tried cases in court or primarily settled out of court.

What Is Your Success Rate in Car Accident Cases?

Before choosing a car accident attorney in New York, ask about their settlement and verdict history to gauge their capability. Request examples of cases they’ve won, and listen to how confidently they share these experiences with you without making embellishments. Be wary of anyone who talks a big game but provides few concrete examples.

How Will You Communicate With Me During This Case?

Communication can make or break your attorney-client relationship going forward. Ask how often you’ll receive updates about your case, whether the attorney will personally handle your case, and which paralegal will manage the groundwork. Firms that take days to respond to inquiries can leave you feeling anxious and uninformed during an already stressful time.

What Fees Does Your Car Accident Lawyer in Queens, NY, Charge?

Understanding the cost of legal representation and jurisdiction is crucial. Some New York car accident lawyers may do things differently, so confirm details like whether they work on a contingency fee basis or charge additional costs. Some firms charge extra for filing fees or expert witness fees, while others take those costs from the settlement.

How To Select a Good Accident Lawyer in New York

The U.S. Department of Transportation reported that 43,230 people were killed in vehicle crashes in 2021, including around 7,388 pedestrians. These cases abound, but your lawyer shouldn’t make you feel like another case number. Beyond asking questions, pay attention to how the attorney makes you feel and whether they actively listen to your concerns.

Does the attorney explain the legal concepts in plain language and avoid talking over you? What do the firm’s online testimonials or ratings reveal about previous clients’ experiences? You’ll also want to check that the attorney is licensed to practice in New York (the New York State Bar Association provides this information publicly).

Lastly, consider the firm’s resources. Larger firms may have more resources to dedicate to your case, although smaller firms can often mean more personalized attention. It’s important to look at it from all angles and confirm the details that will help you build trust with your legal representative.

Red Flags To Watch For in a New York Car Accident Lawyer

What should make you think twice about hiring a specific attorney? 

  • The attorney talks badly about the legal profession or other lawyers. 
  • The attorney uses pressure tactics to rush you into signing a contract.
  • The attorney tells you exactly what settlement amount you’ll receive.
  • The attorney seems more interested in settling quickly than maximizing your payout. 

A good lawyer is willing to negotiate aggressively and go to trial if that’s what your case requires.

The Consultation Process After Your Car Accident

Car accident attorneys generally offer free initial consultations so that you have an opportunity to share your story and evaluate the attorney before committing. Come prepared with documentation like police reports, medical records, and any communication with insurance companies. You’ll also want to prepare some questions, like those above, to ask your accident attorney to properly gauge your case’s strengths and weaknesses.

During this consultation, the attorney should explain the legal process, potential challenges, and realistic timelines. They should also discuss their communication policies and fee structure clearly.

Make Elliot Ifraimoff & Associates, PC, Your Partner in Car Accident Claims in New York

Choosing the right car accident lawyer in New York is just as important as filing a car accident claim on time. The attorneys at Elliot Ifraimoff & Associates, PC, have helped countless New York car accident victims navigate the system and can guide you through every step. For a free consultation with a New York car accident lawyer, call (888) 275-3554 (toll-free) or (718) 205-1010

Preguntas frecuentes

Here are answers to common questions about hiring a New York car accident lawyer.

When Should I Contact a Lawyer After My Car Accident?

Whether you’re involved in a collision in New York or in another state, you should contact a car accident lawyer as soon as possible, ideally within the first few days. It’s important to know your rights in the state, gather evidence before it disappears, and understand the filing deadline and statute of limitations.

Can I Switch Lawyers if I’m Unhappy With My Current Representation?

Yes, you can switch car accident lawyers at any time. Remember to confirm whether you owe your original attorney fees for work already completed. These details will depend on your contract terms.

What if I Can’t Afford To Pay a Lawyer Up Front?

Many car accident lawyers work on a contingency basis, meaning your attorney only collects a fee if they win your case. However, you should confirm this with your chosen lawyer.

How Do I Choose Between Multiple Qualified Car Accident Lawyers?

When choosing a New York car accident lawyer, compare several attorneys’ experiences and outcomes with cases like yours. It’s also helpful to review their communication style and fee structures before committing.